GuideJune 18, 2025· Updated November 5, 2026· 61 views

How to use data to negotiate salary: six sources, one range (2026)

Glassdoor, Indeed, BLS and the employer's posted range will each give you a different number for the same job. Here is what each source measures, how to turn them into one salary range you can defend, and how that range works in an offer negotiation and in a raise request.

Alex Vavilov

Alex Vavilov

CEO at Glozo | Helping Recruiters & Agencies Cut Sourcing Time by 80% with our Talent Intelligence Platform

Text cover for a guide on how to use salary data to negotiate pay: read six sources and turn them into one defensible range.

To use data in a salary negotiation, you need one range you can defend, built from sources that describe the same job, level and city as yours. Finding a number on Glassdoor takes a minute. The work is in what comes next: BLS, Glassdoor, Indeed and the employer's own posted range will each give you a different figure, and each one is right about something different.

Most people never get that far. In a Pew Research Center survey published in April 2023, about three in ten U.S. workers said they asked for more than the first offer the last time they were hired (32% of men, 28% of women). Of those who asked, 66% got more than they were first offered.

Below: what each salary source counts, how to reconcile them, a worked example for a data analyst offer in Chicago, and how the same numbers work differently in an offer negotiation and in a raise request.

What each salary data source actually measures

Salary sources disagree because they count different people and different pay. Before you put two numbers side by side, check who reported them, whether they are base or total pay, which experience levels are mixed in, and how old they are.

Source What it counts Where it misleads Use it for
BLS OEWS Wages employers report for each occupation code, by state and metro area Broad codes, every experience level in one number, published about a year after the survey month A check on the middle of the market
Pay range in a job posting What one employer expects to pay for one opening Ranges often cover several levels, and most hires land in the lower half That employer's budget for the role
Indeed salary pages Pay listed in job postings on Indeed, usually over the past 36 months Advertised pay, all levels mixed, older postings included A floor for the market
Glassdoor Pay that employees report anonymously, with base and additional pay shown separately Self-selected reporters, loose job titles, mixed levels The base pay people in the job say they get
Levels.fyi Total compensation submissions by level, mostly from tech and large companies Thin outside tech, and the figures include stock, so they can't be compared with base pay Total pay at companies with formal levels
PayScope An estimate for one resume: your role, level and skills compared with over 30 million job listings in your city An estimate built from advertised pay, not a payroll survey A range matched to your level in one step

The BLS figure deserves a closer look because people treat it as the official answer. Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) wages leave out overtime and year-end bonuses, and the latest release covers May 2025. That makes it a good check on the middle of an occupation as of a year ago. It says much less about what one level of one job pays today.

PayScope also publishes medians by level and city for more than 25 roles in its salary guides. If your role has a guide, it is a quick way to see how much pay changes between levels before you look at anything else.

How to turn several numbers into one salary range

Work through these six steps in order. Each one removes a reason two sources disagree.

1. Match the job, not the title

Job titles are loose. BLS has no "data analyst" code at all: the nearest one, Data Scientists (15-2051), also covers business intelligence analysts and data scientists, so it reads high for most analyst jobs. On Glassdoor and Indeed the opposite happens, and a title like "analyst" can pull in entry-level reporting jobs. Read the duties and the required years of experience before you trust a figure.

2. Put every number on the same basis

Base pay and total pay are different numbers. Glassdoor shows them separately, Levels.fyi leads with total compensation, and BLS sits in between because it includes commissions but leaves out year-end bonuses. Compare base with base. If the offer includes a bonus, compare that separately.

3. Adjust for your level

Most free sources average every experience level together. If the pool is mostly junior postings, the average sits below a mid-level candidate. If it is mostly people who bothered to report a good salary, it sits above. Ask which way each source leans for someone with your years of experience.

4. Check the date

Indeed's salary pages draw on up to 36 months of postings, and the newest BLS data describes May 2025. U.S. salary increase budgets have run at about 3.5% a year (WTW, July 2026), so a figure built on three-year-old pay can sit roughly 10% behind the current market.

5. Read posted ranges for what they are

A posted range shows what the employer has budgeted for the opening. When Glassdoor compared posted ranges with the salaries people later reported, 67% of salaries fell inside the range, 22% below it and 11% above it, and more than 60% landed below the midpoint. Treat the midpoint as the upper part of the realistic zone for most hires. Our guide to what a salary range in a job posting means covers how to read one in detail.

6. Write down a band

After the adjustments, look for where the readings overlap. That overlap is your market band. A band built from named sources also shows the recruiter exactly where your number comes from.

Worked example: a data analyst offer in Chicago

Maya (invented for this example) has five years of experience as a data analyst and an offer from a Chicago company at $92,000 base. Since January 1, 2025, Illinois has required employers with 15 or more employees to include a pay scale and benefits in job postings, so she can compare the offer with posted ranges as well as with the usual salary sites. The figures below come from Indeed, Glassdoor, BLS OEWS and a BMO job posting on Indeed, all captured on November 5, 2026.

Source Figure What it covers How Maya reads it
Indeed, Chicago $80,868 average base ($53,979 to $121,152), plus about $2,000 cash bonus 212 salaries from Indeed job postings over the past 36 months, updated October 29, 2026 Every level and three years of postings: a floor for her
Glassdoor, Chicago $98K average base ($76K to $125K) 925 anonymous reports as of November 2026 Close to the middle for her level
BLS OEWS, Chicago metro, May 2025 $107,640 median ($84,600 at the 25th percentile, $138,210 at the 75th) Data Scientists (15-2051), the nearest code, 7,940 jobs A ceiling, because the code includes data scientists
BMO posting on Indeed $65,000 to $140,000, midpoint $102,500 One Data Analyst opening asking for 4 to 6 years of experience Her exact level, with most hires landing below the midpoint

Read together, Indeed marks the floor and BLS the ceiling. Glassdoor's average base and the BMO midpoint meet between $98,000 and $102,500, and the Glassdoor range study says most hires land below a posted midpoint. Maya's market band for base pay is $95,000 to $105,000. The offer sits $3,000 below the bottom of it.

Her notes for the call fit in two lines:

Data analysts, 4 to 6 years, Chicago, base pay:
Glassdoor average $98K (925 reports, Nov 2026); BMO posting for the same experience $65,000 to $140,000; BLS nearest occupation median $107,640 (May 2025).

The data can't tell Maya which number to ask for, how far above the band to open, or what to say if the recruiter calls the budget fixed. Those answers depend on the whole offer and on how much she wants this job.

Using salary data when you negotiate a job offer

At the offer stage, the employer's budget is the posted range plus whatever the hiring manager can get approved above it. Your data has one job: showing that the number you want sits inside what the market pays for this level in this city.

  • Name the source and the date. "Glassdoor, 925 reports, November 2026" is harder to wave away than "the market says".
  • Use the employer's own posted range when you have it. A recruiter has little room to dispute their own job posting.
  • Compare base with base. If they offer a bonus or equity, value it separately so the base doesn't absorb it.
  • Keep the spreadsheet to yourself. One or two sources said out loud carry more weight than a list of ten.

If the recruiter asks for your number before there is an offer, see how to answer the salary expectations question. If you're worried that asking at all could cost you the job, read whether you can lose a job offer by negotiating.

Using salary data when you ask for a raise

With your current employer, two numbers matter: the market rate for your role and the company's raise budget. WTW's July 2026 survey of 1,650 U.S. organizations found salary increase budgets of 3.5% in 2026 and 3.4% planned for 2027. A standard merit raise lands close to that budget.

Market data tells you whether you need more than a merit raise. Say Maya took the job at $92,000 and is still there a year later. A 3.5% raise adds $3,220. Reaching $100,000, the middle of her band, takes 8.7%. A gap that size is a market adjustment, a separate request with its own budget at many companies, and the data is what justifies it.

The strongest data point is often inside your own company. The same Illinois law requires employers to tell current employees about open positions. If your company posts your own title with a range that starts above your pay, that is the company's own number, and it is hard to argue with.

How to build the case, when to ask, and the emails to send are in our guide on how to ask for a raise.

Mistakes people make with salary data

  • Comparing an average with a median. Indeed shows averages, BLS shows medians, and a few high earners pull an average up.
  • Mixing base and total pay. A Levels.fyi total next to a base offer makes the offer look worse than it is.
  • Treating the top of a posted range as the target. Fewer than one in eight salaries lands above a posted range.
  • Using a national figure for a city job. Pay for the same role varies widely between metros, so match the location to the job.
  • Quoting old data as current. Adjust anything older than a year, and say how old it is.
  • Citing a source you can't explain. If the recruiter asks what the number covers and you don't know, it stops helping you.

Frequently Asked Questions

What data should I use to negotiate my salary? Use at least three sources that measure different things: a government source such as BLS OEWS for the middle of the occupation, a self-reported source such as Glassdoor for base pay by city, and posted pay ranges for the employer's budget. Match the job duties and your experience level before comparing them, and turn the overlap into a band rather than a single number.

Is BLS salary data good enough for a salary negotiation? BLS OEWS data is reliable for the middle of an occupation in a metro area, but it mixes all experience levels, uses broad occupation codes and is about a year old when published. Use it as a check on other sources rather than as your main number, and name the occupation code and the survey month if you cite it.

What should I do if my salary sources disagree? Find out why before you average them. Most gaps come from four differences: base versus total pay, which experience levels are included, how old the data is, and how closely the job title matches yours. Once each figure is adjusted for those, the readings usually overlap, and the overlap is your range.

Should I tell the employer where my salary numbers come from? Yes, briefly. Naming one or two sources with their dates, such as a Glassdoor figure and the employer's own posted range, makes your number harder to dismiss. Keep the full comparison to yourself and avoid sources you can't explain if asked.

How old can salary data be before it stops being useful? Data older than about a year should be adjusted before you rely on it. U.S. salary increase budgets have run near 3.5% a year (WTW, 2026), so pay data from three years ago can be roughly 10% behind the current market. Always say how old a figure is when you cite it.

Can I use a job posting from my own company to ask for a raise? Yes, and it is often the strongest evidence available, because the range is the company's own number. If your employer posts your title with a range that starts above your current pay, bring the posting and its date to the conversation and ask how your pay compares with that range.

Once you have a band you can defend, the next step is deciding what to ask for inside it.

Alex Vavilov

Alex Vavilov

CEO at Glozo | Helping Recruiters & Agencies Cut Sourcing Time by 80% with our Talent Intelligence Platform